Top 12 Best Toilet Seat Reviews 2019 & Guide

Last Updated: February 24th, 2019

There is nothing more disheartening than a toilet seat that looks like it has been around for fifty years. When it is time to buy a new toilet seat, it can be an overwhelming task because there are so many toilet seat products available. We will make your selection process as easy as possible by providing you with some product reviews to consider.

Top 12 Toilet Seats

When selecting a toilet seat you need to consider more than just the color and shape. Toilet seats come with soft-closing lids for a quieter operation. There are new advances in hinges that provide a quick-release option. This allows you to remove the toilet seat easily for better toilet cleaning. Look at our top 12 favorite toilet seats and see if any of them are appealing.

1. Kohler White K-4636-0 Cachet Elongated White Toilet Seat

Buy from Amazon

There is nothing more annoying than a toilet seat that slams shut when you try to close it. That’s why I really like this toilet seat from Kohler. It has a quiet-close lid that closes slowly and quietly without slamming. Grip-tight bumpers add stability to this seat and prevent it from shifting when you are sitting on it.

It has quick-release hinges which allow you to unlatch the toilet seat from the toilet for better cleaning accessibility. This polypropylene toilet seat is resistant to staining, fading and chipping. Kohler offers a 1-year limited warranty on this product.

Pros:

• Made of polypropylene
• Lid closes slowly and quietly
• Quick-release hinges allow the seat to be unlatched from the toilet
• Resistant to staining, fading and chipping
• 1-year limited warranty

Cons:

• Lid falls right away after letting go of it from the upright position
• Lid buckles when you sit on it

2. Bemis White 1500EC Wood Elongated Toilet Seat

Buy from Amazon

This elongated toilet seat from Bemis is made from molded wood with a multi-coat enamel finish. The seat has color-matching Easy Clean and Change hinges that allow you to remove the seat for easy cleaning. The hinges include non-corrosive bolts that tighten on the top.

The hinges on this seat differ from traditional bolts that are installed by passing the bolts through the hinges. These bolts are first attached to the toilet bowl. The hinges on the seat are then turned to lock the seat in place.

They make the two bumpers on the seat of rubber instead of wood so that the seat does not slam when it is closed. This is a high-quality toilet seat and lid cover that will be an asset for your bathroom.

Pros:

• Made of molded wood
• Multi-coat enamel finish
• Matching hinges
• Bolts are attached to toilet and hinges screw into the bolts
• Rubber bumpers

Cons:

• No installation instructions

3. Bath Royale White Round Toilet Seat

Buy from Amazon

Do you have a toilet that does not have standard seat mounting hole spacings? If so then this toilet seat from Bath Royale will solve your toilet seat problems! This seat fits all toilet brands including any with non-standard hole spacings. The only type of fixture this seat will not work with is a bidet that installs between the seat and the bowl.

The polypropylene design of this toilet seat makes it more durable than wooden seats. The seat and lid can hold up to 400 pounds making this a great solution for obese individuals. The seat has 4 seat bumpers to distribute the weight evenly.

The quiet-close feature of this toilet seat prevents loud slamming of the lid when you are closing it. The seat has a non-porous, chemical and stain-resistant finish  which will not chip, peel or fade. Bath Royale offers a 2-year warranty on this product which is double most toilet seat warranties.

Pros:

• Fits all toilet brands
• Fits toilets with non-standard hole spacings
• Offers support for heavy person
• 4 seat bumpers to distribute weight evenly
• 2-year warranty

Cons:

• Loosens easily and needs to be re-tightened
• Lid does not stay open when placed in the upright position

4. Toto Cotton White SS114 01 Elongated Toilet Seat

Buy from Amazon

This polypropylene toilet seat by Toto has a soft-closing lid action to eliminate the toilet seat slam noise. It uses a built-in SoftClose hinge system which lowers the seat gently. There are top-tightening mounting bolts to ensure an easy installation process. There is a long plastic plate along the back of the toilet seat to cover the hinges.

This toilet has a comfortable ergonomic design for all users. Molded bumpers help to keep the toilet seat in place so it does not slide around. Toto offers a 1-year limited warranty on this product.

Pros:

• Soft-closing lid
• Top-tightening mounting bolts
• Molded bumpers
• 1-year limited warranty

Cons:

• Plastic hinge plate is weak and may crack over time

5. Delta White 811903-WH Elongated Toilet Seat

Buy from Amazon

This Delta toilet seat has a slow-close feature to prevent the toilet lid from slamming when it is lowered. There are 4 non-slip seat bumpers to distribute weight evenly and keep the seat from shifting. This seat will fit most elongated bowls, but be sure to take measurements of your bowl before you buy this seat to make sure it will fit.

This seat uses screw in plastic bolts to hold the hinges in place and prevent loosening. Its plastic construction makes this seat resistant to staining, fading, chipping and peeling. This seat is not intended for commercial use, but will fit in well with your bathroom decor.

Pros:

• Slow-closing lid
• 4 non-slip bumpers
• Elongated
• 1-year limited warranty

Cons:

• No installation instructions
• Seat does not stay still
• Bolts are not long enough

6. Topseat Wood TinyHiney Potty Elongated Toilet Seat with Chromed Metal Hinges

Buy from Amazon

This innovative toilet seat from Topseat is a perfect solution for your little one who is learning how to use the toilet on their own. This 2-in-1 seat not only includes an adult ring, but it has a secondary toddler-sized ring that will not pull off and is completely safe and secure.

The toddler seat secures magnetically into the lid cover to keep it out of the way when it is not in use. Bumpers under the toddler seat will prevent little fingers from being pinched between the seats.

Topseat makes this product out of durable wood construction. It is hand-sanded with a high-gloss painted white finish. The stylish chromed metal hinges have an optional slow-close function available. Topseat offers a 3-year warranty for this toilet seat.

Pros:

• 2-in-1 toilet seat
• Toddler seat magnetically fits into lid cover when not in use
• Made of wood
• Chromed metal hinges
• Optional slow-close function
• 3-year warranty

Cons:

• Hinge screws loosen easily
• Slow-close function does not work well

7. Bemis 800EC White Plastic Round Toilet Seat

Buy from Amazon

This toilet seat has easy, clean and change hinges that twist to remove the seat for easy cleaning and replacement. The injection molded solid plastic seat design features four molded-in bumpers that are color-matched to the seat. This seat is in compliance with regulations as a commercial heavy duty toilet seat.

The seat weighs only 4.2 pounds and is extremely easy to install. The plastic construction is very sturdy and works well for obese individuals. If you are looking for a solution to an outhouse installation, this toilet seat is definitely one to consider. It is a great fit for outhouse installations especially if you follow the cleaning instructions and avoid abrasive cleaners and brushes.

Pros:

• Made of plastic
• Four molded-in bumpers
• Can be used in commercial settings

Cons:

• Bolts loosen quickly

8. Bemis Mayfair Entry Level White Round Toilet Seat

Buy from Amazon

This toilet seat has a Top-Tite Sta-Tite seat fastening system which installs from the top. This prevents you from having to crawl around on the floor like you have to for traditional toilet seats to get the bolts fastened. The solid plastic construction resists chips, wear and stains.

This toilet seat fits all round toilets and is proudly made in the USA with earth friendly materials and processes. This seat is durable and can be used in commercial settings. Bemis offers a 1-year warranty on this toilet seat.

Pros:

• Hinge fastening system installs from the top
• Solid plastic construction
• Resists chips, wear and stains
• Made in the USA
• 1-year warranty

Cons:

• Easily moves side to side
• Difficult to tighten hinges

9. Mayfair 13EC White Round Soft Padded Toilet Seat with Wood Core

Buy from Amazon

Do you dislike sitting on cold hard toilet seats when you are taking care of business in the bathroom? Then consider this round padded toilet seat from Mayfair. The soft cushioned seat will give you comfort while you are using the toilet and the wood core will give you years of long-lasting durability.

The entire toilet seat can be easily removed for cleaning or replacement. Simply unsnap the hinge covers and lift the toilet seat off of the toilet. You should use a mild soap on this cushioned toilet seat to keep it looking brand new. The 1-year warranty makes this a risk-free choice for your toilet seat needs.

Pros:

• Soft, cushioned vinyl seat
• Wood core for durability
• Easy remove hinges
• 1-year warranty

Cons:

• Vinyl can tear easily
• Vinyl may discolor

10. Vive Elongated Toilet Seat Riser with Handles and Padded Arms

Buy from Amazon

If you are looking for a toilet seat that will work for an elderly person or someone with mobility issues, then this product from Vive is one to consider. This riser fits under your existing toilet seat and adds 3.5-inches of height to the  toilet seat. This makes it easier to stand or sit without bending. This is a safe solution for the elderly or those recovering from surgery.

Removable handles are padded with soft foam hand grips to provide additional help when standing up or sitting down at the toilet. The handles offer a non-slip surface for a safe and secure grip. The width between the handles is a comfortable 22-inches.

This durable composite toilet seat riser supports up to 300 pounds. You can clean this seat riser with regular household disinfectants or sanitizing wipes. The handles are made with corrosion-resistant aluminum.

Pros:

• Riser seat adds 3.5-inches of height to your existing seat
• Removable handles
• Non-slip handle grips
• Supports up to 300 pounds

Cons:

• Side handles get in the way of wiping
• Riser bolt holes do not fit all toilet bowls

11. Bath Royale Premium Elongated Family Toilet Seat with Built-In Child Seat

Buy from Amazon

Do you have a small child who is being potty-trained? Then this Bath Royale toilet seat with built-in child seat may be the right choice for you to consider. This innovative seat eliminates clutter in your bathroom with the 2-in-1 seat design.

The built-in toddler seat attachment allows your toddler to sit directly on the toilet seat without having to fuss around with a potty ring or training seat. The toddler ring fits securely inside the toilet seat lid and can be stored out of the way once your toddler can go potty alone. The seat has been tested up to 400 pounds and the seat and cover will flex but will not crack or break. There are four non-slip bumpers on the bottom of the seat lid to distribute the weight evenly.

The 100% polypropylene material is non-porous and resistant to chemicals and stains. This toilet seat is a perfect choice if you are looking for an option to potty-train your child.

Pros:

• 2-in-1 toilet seat
• Toddler seat fits into lid cover when not in use
• Made of plastic
• Slow-close function

Cons:

• Hinge screws loosen easily
• Seat wiggles around

12. Carex White Elongated Toilet Seat Riser

Buy from Amazon

The Carex raised toilet seat is a perfect solution for anyone recovering from surgery or for the elderly. This seat adds 3.5-inches of height to your existing toilet seat. It can support a weight capacity of 300 pounds. This toilet seat does not have to be locked which makes it quite portable.

When you install this toilet seat, you simply remove your existing toilet seat and install it on top of the riser. The long bolts that come with this seat are very long to ensure you have a secure foundation. Although this toilet seat does not include any handles, it is still ideal for anyone who needs some extra care and help after surgery or for a loved one.

Pros:

• Easy to install
• Adds 3.5-inches to existing toilet seat
• Supports up to 300 pounds

Cons:

• Does not include non-slip grip handles
• Hinges become loose after a while

Features to Consider in a Toilet Seat

There are many characteristics of a toilet seat to consider before choosing one to buy. Toilet seats are definitely a personal preference, but consider the following features before making a final decision.

Soft-Closing Lid

Have you ever tried to lower a toilet lid and had it slip from your fingers? When this happens, you will often hear a very loud slamming sound! This can make everyone cringe at the noise.

Many of the toilet seats available on the market have a soft-closing lid feature. This allows you to tilt a toilet seat forward slightly from the upright position and it will slowly fall into place against the toilet without making any sound at all.

If you want to keep your bathroom business quiet, then consider a toilet seat with a soft-closing lid!

Installation Holes

If you have an older toilet, there is a good chance that the seat holes in the toilet bowl have non-standard spacing. Be sure you measure the distance between the hinge holes in your toilet bowl and compare that distance with any toilet seat you are considering. Standard spacing will be anywhere from 4-inches to 7-inches.

Bumpers

Most toilet seats have bumpers underneath the seat. The purpose of these bumpers is to eliminate the slipping and sliding motion of the seat. The design of the bumpers allows them to grip the toilet seat.

Rubber bumpers will make the least noise, but they may also wear more quickly. If you have plastic or wood bumpers, they may last longer but also slide around more on the slick toilet surface.

Be sure to read the reviews of any toilet seat you consider and identify any known issues or complaints with the bumpers.

Quick Removal

Many toilet seats have an easy installation process that lends itself to a quick removal of the seat for cleaning purposes. Special hinges allow the seat to unlatch quickly from the toilet bowl. This gives you better access for thoroughly cleaning the full toilet bowl without having the seat in the way.

Conclusion

Everyone has to use the bathroom at some point during the day. You may as well be sure you have a durable toilet seat that does not move around and is comfortable. We have shared several product reviews and some features to consider when searching for a new toilet seat. If you do the proper research, you will make a smart choice and will not regret your decision.